Cleveland Brothers at 78: The Pennsylvania CAT Dealer With a Surprising New York Connection

Cleveland Brothers Equipment Company has served as the exclusive Caterpillar dealer for western, central, and northeastern Pennsylvania, northern West Virginia, and western Maryland since 1948. That's a straightforward, 78-year family-dealer story on its own. What makes it genuinely interesting is the part most Pennsylvania contractors have probably never heard: Cleveland Brothers shares a direct family origin with a completely different CAT dealer, 150 miles away in New York, and the story of how the two companies split apart says something real about how dealer territories get built and unwound.

Two Brothers, One Rejected Deal

Before Cleveland Brothers existed, Robert W. Cleveland Sr. and his brother Royal E. (Roy) Cleveland ran a construction company, Robert W. Cleveland & Company, out of New Jersey. The brothers approached Caterpillar about acquiring H.O. Penn Machinery Company, the CAT dealer covering New York City, Long Island, and the lower Hudson Valley since 1933. Caterpillar turned them down: H.O. Penn had already been taken over by two of its own key employees, Ralph Johnson and Stuart Wade.

Rather than walking away empty-handed, Caterpillar offered the brothers something else in 1948: a new, unclaimed territory in central Pennsylvania that had formerly belonged to Beckwith Machinery. The Clevelands accepted, and Cleveland Brothers Equipment Company was born out of what started as a failed acquisition attempt. It's a reminder that the biggest, most important moment in a company's history sometimes starts as the deal that didn't work out.

When the Family Got Both Dealerships Anyway

Here's where the story gets genuinely unusual. At some point after Cleveland Brothers was established in Pennsylvania, Caterpillar did approve the Cleveland Brothers Equipment Company's acquisition of H.O. Penn, the very dealership the brothers had originally been turned down for. For a stretch, H.O. Penn and Cleveland Brothers shared common ownership while operating as entirely separate businesses: Bob Cleveland moved to New York to run H.O. Penn, while Roy stayed in Pennsylvania to run Cleveland Brothers.

That arrangement didn't last forever. A few years later, the two companies split for good. Bob Cleveland and his family took controlling interest of H.O. Penn, while Roy Cleveland and his family became the sole owners of Cleveland Brothers Equipment Company. From that point forward, the two dealers ran as fully independent businesses, each covering its own territory, each carrying its own name, and each run by its own branch of the same family.

Bob Cleveland Sr. went on to serve as H.O. Penn's President from 1965 to 1975 and then as Chairman of the Board until his death in 1990. His sons continued the family's involvement there: Bob Jr. served as President from 1975 to 1985, and C.E. Thomas Cleveland, who joined the firm in 1968, saw his own son Rob join H.O. Penn in 1995. Rob Cleveland currently serves as H.O. Penn's Chairman of the Board, meaning a third generation of the same Cleveland family that founded Cleveland Brothers in Pennsylvania is still actively running a separate CAT dealership in New York today.

What a Split Family Dealer Story Actually Tells You

Most of the dealer-history pieces in this series cover a single, continuous family business. Cleveland Brothers' story is different precisely because it shows how fluid dealer territory assignments and ownership structures can be, even within one family. A rejected acquisition became an entirely new dealership; a shared-ownership arrangement became two fully separate companies; and the same bloodline ended up anchoring two unrelated regional CAT dealers for 75-plus years, neither one dependent on the other's success.

For a Pennsylvania contractor today, none of that New York history changes anything about the dealer actually serving your territory. But it's a useful reminder that a dealer's name on the showroom sign often has a more complicated, more interesting backstory than a straightforward founding date suggests, and that Caterpillar's own dealer network has been shaped as much by family relationships and historical accident as by pure business strategy.

78 Years Serving a Demanding Multi-State Territory

Cleveland Brothers' current territory, western, central, and northeastern Pennsylvania, northern West Virginia, and western Maryland, covers a genuinely varied set of industries. The company's own materials cite construction, oil and gas, power generation, paving, and landscaping among the sectors it supports. That range reflects the Marcellus Shale gas boom that's reshaped a huge swath of Pennsylvania and West Virginia over the past two decades, alongside the older, steadier demand from highway construction, commercial building, and the Appalachian coal and timber economy that's run through this region for generations.

A dozer working a Marcellus Shale well-pad site and an excavator working a highway resurfacing job in the same county both trace back to the same 78-year-old dealer network, a network that's had to stock and staff for both the energy boom and the steadier infrastructure work simultaneously.

Why This History Matters More Than It Seems To

It's tempting to treat a dealer's founding story as trivia, interesting but irrelevant to an actual equipment purchase. That's usually true, but Cleveland Brothers' story is a genuine exception, because the split from H.O. Penn tells you something concrete about independence and focus. Once the two companies separated for good, Cleveland Brothers wasn't managing a second territory three states away or splitting attention between two unrelated markets. Roy Cleveland's family built a single-territory operation and kept building it for over seven decades, which tends to produce deeper local knowledge and faster decision-making than a dealer juggling multiple disconnected regions. A dealer that isn't dividing executive attention across unrelated geographies can generally move faster on the decisions that actually affect a contractor's day-to-day service experience, from stocking a specific attachment to approving a warranty claim.

Compare that focus to Finning, which deliberately built a six-country operation, or Warren CAT, which grew by methodically acquiring adjacent territory. Cleveland Brothers represents a third model entirely: one family, one well-defined multi-state region, built and defended for nearly 80 years without the complexity of running unrelated markets. None of these models is inherently better, but they produce genuinely different dealer organizations, and it's worth knowing which kind you're actually dealing with.

The Rent-vs-Own Decision for a Boom-and-Steady Territory

Pennsylvania and West Virginia's natural gas sector runs in cycles tied to commodity prices, while highway and municipal infrastructure work tends to be steadier and less volatile. A site-prep contractor who's diversified across both, taking gas-pad work when it's active and falling back on municipal paving and grading contracts when it slows, is exactly the kind of business that benefits most from owning core equipment rather than renting job to job. Rental costs don't flex downward when a boom pauses; owned equipment that's paid off, or financed on reasonable terms, keeps working for you regardless of which sector is hot that year.

Financing for Pennsylvania, West Virginia, and Maryland Contractors

BFC Equipment Loans finances and leases construction equipment nationwide, for startups and existing businesses, with good credit or bad, regardless of whether your business runs on steady municipal contracts, cyclical energy-sector work, or some mix of both. That flexibility matters in a territory like Cleveland Brothers' own, where diversification across sectors is often the difference between a contractor that survives a gas-price downturn and one that doesn't.

• Marcellus Shale well-pad and pipeline site-prep contractors across Pennsylvania and West Virginia

• Highway and municipal infrastructure subcontractors working central and western Pennsylvania

• Commercial and residential site development contractors in the Pittsburgh and Harrisburg metros

• Landscaping and land-clearing businesses scaling up equipment for larger commercial contracts

Whichever sector your business serves, and whichever dealer you buy from, the financing conversation is the same: a structure that fits your actual revenue pattern, not a generic formula that assumes every month looks the same. That's the conversation worth having before your next equipment purchase.

A Family Story Worth Knowing, Whichever Dealer You Use

Whether or not the H.O. Penn connection ever comes up in conversation with your local Cleveland Brothers rep, it's a genuinely good story, the kind that makes an industry feel smaller and more human than the corporate press releases usually suggest. A rejected acquisition in New York became a thriving, independent dealership in Pennsylvania; a brief shared-ownership arrangement became two separate family legacies; and 78 years later, both companies are still standing, still family-connected at the root, and still serving contractors who've probably never heard either half of the story. That's worth appreciating, even if it changes nothing about the financing decision in front of you.

Ready to Put This Machine to Work?

Whatever brought you to this page, the next step is the same: see what you qualify for. BFC Equipment Loans finances and leases construction equipment nationwide for startups and existing businesses, good credit or bad, in all 50 states. Apply for equipment financing and get real numbers back, not a runaround. Looking to buy or sell a machine outright instead? Browse our equipment for sale and financing marketplace. And if you want more of this kind of coverage in your inbox, subscribe to the BFC blog for weekly equipment and financing breakdowns.