Hyundai HX85A vs. New Holland E85D: Two 8.5-Ton Excavators, One Big Difference in Tail Swing

Hyundai's HX85A and New Holland's E85D sit almost exactly on top of each other by name and by weight class, which makes this one of the more natural head-to-head comparisons in the 8.5-ton excavator bracket — and one that hasn't been written about before despite how directly these two machines compete.

A Transitional Machine for Both Brands

The HX85A holds a distinct place in Hyundai's lineup: it was the company's first compact excavator included among the A-Series machines and the first to carry an HX model designation, filling the gap between Hyundai's compact and full-sized excavator ranges. There's no clean prior Hyundai model it directly replaces — it's a genuinely transitional addition to the lineup rather than a generational update, and it's worth saying that plainly rather than inventing a predecessor that doesn't exist. At 65 hp from a Yanmar 4TNV98C-PHYB engine and 19,026 lbs operating weight, it digs to 15 feet 0.7 inches and reaches 24 feet 4.1 inches, with 13,852 lbs of bucket breakout force and 8,338 lbs of arm crowd force. Swing speed comes in at 9.5 rpm and maximum travel speed at 3.2 mph.

New Holland's E85D is the flagship of the D-Series midi excavator range, running 73 hp from a Yanmar 4TNV98C-T — the same engine family Hyundai uses in the HX85A, worth noting — at 19,467 lbs operating weight, with a 12-foot-6-inch dig depth and true zero tailswing. Its main pump delivers 50.7 gallons per minute, and bucket breakout force comes in at 13,151 lbf with arm tearout at 9,779 lbf — both close to the HX85A's numbers despite the different swing geometry and roughly 8 hp difference in net engine output.

The Real Difference: Tail Swing Configuration

Here's the detail that should actually drive your decision: the HX85A carries a conventional tail swing radius of 5 feet 5.9 inches, while the E85D is true zero tailswing. On an open jobsite, that difference barely registers. Working inside a fenced lot, next to a building, or anywhere clearance behind the machine is tight, it's the deciding factor, full stop — no amount of extra digging reach makes up for clipping a wall on every third swing.

In exchange, the HX85A reaches notably deeper (15 feet versus 12.5 feet) and further (24.3 feet versus the E85D's shorter working envelope), which matters for crews doing utility work or foundation excavation where depth and reach are the binding constraints rather than swing clearance. That's a genuinely significant difference in working envelope — nearly 2.5 extra feet of dig depth is the kind of gap that determines whether a crew can complete a deep utility trench or foundation excavation in a single pass versus having to step the cut or bring in a second, larger machine.

Engine Commonality and What It Means for Parts

Both machines drawing from the same Yanmar 4TNV98C engine family is more than a trivia point — it means the fundamental serviceability of the power plant (filters, injectors, basic overhaul parts) follows a similar pattern across both brands, even though the surrounding fuel system, emissions control, and tuning differ by manufacturer. For a shop that already services one brand's engine family, there's a smaller-than-expected learning curve moving to the other, which can matter if you're considering adding a second brand to an existing fleet rather than staying single-brand for parts simplicity.

Trade Fit

Utility excavation crews, foundation contractors, and site-development subs working in open-to-moderate access conditions will get more value from the HX85A's extra dig depth and reach. Demolition crews, landscape contractors working behind existing structures, and anyone doing regular work in fenced residential lots should prioritize the E85D's true zero tailswing. If you're comparing Hyundai's broader compact lineup, we've also covered how the HX60A compares against the larger HX130A LCR for sizing guidance one step down.

Financing Either Brand

Both machines sit at a price point where excavator financing makes more sense than renting for any contractor using one regularly — a midi excavator in this class rents for real money, and those payments never build equity. BFC finances both Hyundai and New Holland equipment, with down payment terms that scale to your credit profile, from $0 down for well-established businesses to 20-40% for newer operations.

Hydraulic System Design and Attachment Versatility

Both machines offer strong auxiliary hydraulic capability for a midi excavator, supporting hammers, compaction plates, augers, and grapples without a separate flow kit in most configurations. The HX85A's hydraulic system benefits from Hyundai's broader A-Series engineering, which the company says delivers faster cycle speeds across the board compared to its prior generation of compact excavators. The E85D's higher main pump flow of 50.7 gallons per minute gives it a genuine edge for attachments with higher continuous flow demands, a detail worth confirming against the specific attachment lineup you plan to run regularly rather than assuming either machine's base auxiliary package covers everything.

Dealer Network and Service Considerations

Hyundai's North American dealer network has expanded significantly in recent years alongside the broader HD Construction Equipment push into the U.S. market, though it still trails the density of more established brands in some regions. New Holland's construction equipment dealer network, often overlapping with its long-established agricultural equipment dealers, provides broad geographic coverage, particularly in markets with a strong farming or rural construction presence. Before committing to either brand, it's worth confirming realistic service turnaround times with your local dealer rather than assuming national brand reputation translates directly into fast local support.

Sizing Up From Here

If an 8.5-ton midi excavator isn't quite the right size for your work, both manufacturers offer a clear step-up path. Hyundai's next-generation HX Series moves into the 23-to-40-ton range for larger site development and mass excavation work, while New Holland's D-Series tops out at the E85D before stepping into larger excavator classes outside the D-Series line entirely. Understanding where your current job mix sits relative to both manufacturers' full ranges — not just the single model you're comparing today — helps avoid outgrowing a machine within a year or two of financing it.

As with any equipment comparison, treat the figures here as a starting point for a conversation with your dealer rather than a final word — both manufacturers periodically update trim packages and standard equipment within a model's production run, so confirm current specifications on the exact unit you're considering before finalizing a purchase.

Final Thoughts on Making the Call

When two machines are this closely matched in weight class and general capability, the deciding factor often comes down to the one feature that matters most for your specific, repeated work — not the aggregate spec sheet. If tail swing clearance is a daily concern on your jobs, that single factor should outweigh almost everything else in this comparison. If it rarely matters because your work is mostly open-area excavation, the HX85A's extra reach and depth become the more relevant differentiator instead.

Cab Design and Visibility

Visibility is a particularly important factor on a midi excavator working close to obstacles, since the operator needs clear sightlines to judge clearance accurately rather than relying purely on mirrors or cameras. Hyundai's A-Series cab design on the HX85A emphasizes wide glass area and an ergonomic control layout aimed at reducing operator fatigue over long shifts, while New Holland's E85D cab is built around the same automotive-style layout used across the rest of the D-Series lineup, with adjustable controls and the ability to save attachment flow and pressure settings for quick changeovers between tasks. Neither cab is clearly superior on paper — the difference tends to come down to individual operator preference after time in both machines, which is why a test sit or demo day with both before committing is worth the time if your dealer can arrange it.

What a Demo Day Should Actually Test

If you have the opportunity to demo both machines before deciding, focus the comparison on your actual recurring job conditions rather than generic capability. Bring the specific attachments you'd run regularly, work in conditions that mirror your typical jobsite — confined if that's your reality, open if it's not — and pay close attention to how natural the swing-clearance judgment feels on each machine during real rotation near an obstacle. Spec sheets are a starting point, but an hour in the seat of each machine, doing the kind of work you'll actually ask it to do, usually settles a close comparison like this one faster than any amount of additional research.

As with any comparison in this guide, treat the specifications here as a starting point and confirm the exact current configuration with your Hyundai or New Holland dealer before finalizing a purchase decision.

Whichever machine you choose, documenting your decision rationale — tail swing needs, dig depth requirements, dealer proximity — is useful not just for your own records but for any future conversation with a lender about why this specific configuration fits your operation.

See how BFC can help you grow your fleet. Visit our home page, apply for equipment financing, browse our equipment for sale inventory, or subscribe to our blog for more equipment guides.